Ithaca ❤️ Small Business Box

Show your Ithaca love with every bite! This box brings together our signature cookies and hand-picked items from iconic Ithaca small businesses—thoughtful, nostalgic, and full of local flavor. It’s a sweet way to share the heart of the Finger Lakes, no matter where you are.

🏘️ What’s Inside:

Medium Box: Includes 6 of our delicious cookies, sample packet of Ithaca Coffee Co House Blend, Purity Magnet, and Ithaca is Gorges button from Sunny Days.
Large Box: Includes 8 of our cookies, plus everything in the Medium Box and a bag of Ithaca Bakery bagel chips, Collegetown Bagels sticker, and Ithaca Beer Co bottle opener.

Size Medium - $49 Large - $69

View full details

Treat Box Information

Allergens

Our cookies are made by hand in a kitchen that processes dairy, eggs, peanuts, soy, and wheat. If you have a severe allergy, please know that while we do our best to prevent cross-contamination, we are not an allergy-free bakery.

Contains: dairy, eggs, soy, wheat, and peanuts

Care Instructions

Store cookies in a cool, dry place.

Keep them in their packaging until ready to eat.

Cookies are best enjoyed within 10-14 days after arrival.

Shipping Details

Orders typically ship within 3-5 business days. Standard shipping is a flat $5.99, and rush order shipping is available at checkout. For full details, please visit our Shipping Information page.