
Thoughtful Gifts, Deliciously Made

Caffeine Meets Chocolate
The Espresso Brownie Brooklyn Ball is here! Made with 618 Espresso from Seneca Sunrise Coffee, this flavor features a rich brownie base, a silky dark chocolate dip, and a single espresso bean for a bold finish.

Celebrate the Sweet Moments
Planning a celebration? From birthdays to bridal showers, our cookies, Brooklyn Balls, and treat boxes make the perfect party favors!
Now shipping nationwide—with exclusive add-ons for local FLX events!

The Perfect Gift for Every Occasion
Gift "I know you and I love you" in a box! From birthdays to breakups, our curated treat boxes make every moment a little sweeter. Send someone you love a delicious surprise today!

Freshly Baked, Made With Love
Why settle for ordinary when you can have handmade, small-batch cookies baked fresh? If you love classic Chocolate Chip or want to try our signature Coffee Cake cookie, treat yourself or send a gift today!

Stuffed, Dipped, & Irresistible
Brooklyn Balls, our giant stuffed truffles, simply have to be tried to be believed! With flavors like Cookie Dough, Oreo Cheesecake, and Peanut Butter, you'll be wondering where these have been all your life.
Come Find Us!
-
At Your Party
Place an OrderMailing sweet favors across the country? Planning an event here in the Finger Lakes? We've got you covered with custom treats, local delivery, and optional add-ons for extra sparkle.
-
In Stores
Find Goodies Near YouYou can now find Gardella’s Goodies at select local retailers across the Finger Lakes! Stop by one of our partner shops to pick up cookies or Brooklyn Balls.
-
Festivals
Come Say HiWe’re hitting the road with cookies, Brooklyn Balls, and treat boxes in tow! Catch us at local festivals, pop-ups, and markets across the Finger Lakes — it’s the sweetest way to shop in person.

Thank You!
Gardella’s Goodies is a dream realized and a tribute to love, family, and all the little moments that have shaped us. After years spent in Brooklyn and with countless memories of baking with Lauren’s grandmother, Joan, we were inspired to share our passion with others. Moving back to Ithaca, the place where we fell in love, has given us the chance to bring Gardella’s Goodies to life.
From our kitchen to yours, we pour our hearts into every treat, honoring those who supported us along the way. Thank you for being part of our journey and supporting our small business!