Flavors
Cookies
Bailey's Irish Cream
A rich brown butter espresso cookie infused with smooth Irish cream flavor, studded with white chocolate chips and finished with a silky Bailey's glaze and cocoa dusting. This one is cozy, decadent, and made for St. Paddy's Day!
Available through March 18th!
Pot of Gold
A soft vanilla cookie loaded with creamy white chocolate chips and bursts of St. Patrick's Day edition Lucky Charms marshmallows! Buttery, nostalgic, and just a little magical, this festive fan favorite is back from last year and tastes like childhood with a grown up bakery twist.
Available through March 18th!
Chocolate Chip
A perfect blend of soft, buttery dough, semi-sweet chocolate chips, and a sprinkle of flaky salt, these cookies deliver the warm nostalgia of home-baked goodness in every bite.
Cookies & Cream
Loaded with white chocolate chips, chunks of cookies + cream chocolate, and crushed Oreo cookie bits, these cookies deliver a decadent combination of textures and flavors in every bite.
Confetti Cake
These cookies feature a buttery, soft dough generously studded with colorful sprinkles that add a delightful crunch and a burst of sweetness. Each bite is a celebration of fun, perfect for any occasion!
Coffee Cake
Soft and flavorful, with hints of warm cinnamon and rich brown sugar in every bite. Topped with a buttery, crumbly streusel and a light dusting of powdered sugar, it's the comforting taste of a classic coffee cake in cookie form.
Red Velvet
These cookies capture the classic flavor of red velvet cake with its signature smooth texture and subtle cocoa notes, enhanced by the luscious white chocolate chips that melt in your mouth for a perfect finish.
Triple Chocolate
The rich flavor of chocolate permeates throughout this cookie, from the velvety dough to the chocolate chips. Experience three types of chocolate blended together to create a rich, fudgy taste that's simply irresistible.
Kitchen Sink
Our ultimate sweet-and-salty cookie mashup! Packed with crunchy pretzels, crispy potato chips, rich chocolate chunks, peanut butter chips, and caramel M&Ms for layers of texture in every bite. Buttery, chewy, salty, and sweet. This is the cookie that truly has it all!
Cherry Liqueur Almond
Studded with tart dried cherries and crunchy slivered almonds, this cookie is infused with Finger Lakes Distilling Cherry Liqueur for deep, fruity flavor with a subtle boozy warmth. Finished with a glossy cherry-almond glaze, it strikes the perfect balance between bright fruit, toasted nuttiness, and gentle sweetness.
Caramel Bourbon Pecan
Made with rich brown butter and chopped pecans, this indulgent cookie is finished with a drizzle of bourbon caramel glaze made using McKenzie Bourbon from Finger Lakes Distilling. Deeply nutty, warmly spiced, and perfectly sweet, each bite delivers caramel richness with a hint of bourbon heat and a touch of sea salt to balance it all out.
S'mores
All the flavors of a campfire classic, baked into one gooey, nostalgic cookie. This soft-baked cookie is loaded with graham cracker flavor, melty mini chocolate bars, and pockets of mini marshmallows for a perfectly balanced bite that’s sweet, buttery, and just a little messy!
Showgirl Mimosa
Bright, bubbly, and made for a main-character moment! This citrus-forward sugar cookie is inspired by Taylor Swift and features a freeze squeezed orange juice and champagne infused base and glaze. Finished with a touch of shimmer and edible sugar, it’s playful, celebratory, and impossible to ignore!
Knapp Limoncello
Made in collaboration with Knapp Winery, this bright, citrus-forward cookie is infused with their signature limoncello right into the dough for bold lemon flavor from the very first bite. Studded with creamy white chocolate chips, and then finished with a tangy limoncello glaze, fresh lemon zest, and a sweet lemon candy on top.
Brooklyn Balls
Peanut Butter Ball
The original ball that started it all! Where creamy peanut butter meets the delightful crunch of rice crispy cereal. Enveloped in a rich milk chocolate coating, this ball is a sweet, nutty indulgence that's impossible to resist!
Oreo Cheesecake Ball
Filled with an Oreo cheesecake interior, this treat is dipped in smooth dark chocolate and topped with a delicious white chocolate drizzle. It’s the perfect balance of crunchy and creamy that will make your taste buds dance!
Cookie Dough Ball
Decadent cookie dough meets a rich chocolate coating. Made with a soft chocolate chip cookie center, dipped in semi-sweet chocolate, and topped with cookie crumbles.
Confetti Cake Ball
A playful mix of vanilla cake and rainbow sprinkles creates a fun, fluffy interior, while the smooth white chocolate coating with more sprinkles adds a sweet pop of color. A party-ready treat that’s as gorgeous as it is delicious!